Joan
Saslow and Allen Ascher. Top Notch 1: English for Today's World,. NY: Pearson
Education, Inc., 2006, Pp.x +128
Top
Notch 1 is the second book of Pearson-Longman's six-level ELT course. This
book, like the other books in the series, aims to provide opportunities for adult
learners to learn natural language by offering teachers a well organized and fully
supported, integrated skills text they can use to draw students into situations
where they can interact with language in real world ways.
The book's ten
units are titled Getting Acquainted; Going Out; Talking about Families; Coping
with Technology; Eating In, Eating Out; Staying in Shape; Finding Something to
Wear; Getting Away; Taking Transportation; and Shopping Smart.
Each of the
ten units offers integrated activities that are related to the overall theme of
the unit. Unit 1, Getting Acquainted, for example, uses realistic and colorful
photos that depict friendly people from different parts of the world in interpersonal
settings to prompt students to exchange personal information and introduce someone
else. The students are then lead through listening, multiple choice, conversation,
grammar, pair work, pronunciation, vocabulary, reading, writing, and finally checkpoint
activities to gauge their progress.
Other units offer similar organization
patterns on different topics: Unit 2 uses entertainment events as prompts for
students to make invitations, talk about likes and dislikes, and give directions;
unit 3 has students explore similarities and differences by describing a family
member and comparing their family to a celebrity's; unit 4's goals include suggesting
a brand, expressing frustration, describing features, and complaining; unit 5
is organized around restaurants, menus and ordering; unit 6 has students discuss
daily exercise and diet; unit 7 focuses on shopping for clothes; unit 8 examines
types of vacations and travel problems; unit 9 looks at different types of vacation
transportation; and unit 10 explores money, travel, and conversations about prices.
In addition to the book's well organized units, the book also offers a
comprehensive reference section at the back which includes an alphabetic word
list, a social language list, and a host of other relevant items.
One
of the features teachers and students may find welcoming is the balanced way the
book addresses grammar. In unit 1, for example, the Topic Preview encourages students
to try out language they already know to motivate them to learn even if they have
trouble expressing themselves before thinking about grammar. Grammar is then addressed
two pages later. This gives students who do not need assistance the opportunity
to move quickly through the grammar section and on to ones where they can expand
on their opinions and contribute more deeply to class discussions while offering
an additional explanation that can be comforting for students who need additional
reassurance.
One possible drawback of the text is its conversation models.
The models may appear simple and less than dynamic at first, but they can indeed
help to warm up the group and get them ready to talk about their own experiences,
engage in role plays, and answer questions. Another possible concern is that the
book's organization may appear light, but teachers will find this uncluttered
layout welcoming as they explore the full range of accompanying materials: a workbook,
a teacher's edition which includes expansion activities, audio and video programs,
placement and assessment packages, and a companion website (www.longman.com/topnotch).
Overall,
ELT teachers who work with adult learners will find Top Notch 1, as well as the
series it is a part of, to be an organized and well supported language learning
package to help their students with their language needs. I would certainly recommend
this book to ELT teachers who wish to ease learners into confidently developing
international communication competence.