| Greece.
There is a two-tiered system of second language
teaching in Greece. At the base level there
is the government school system, whereby students
receive between three and four lessons in English
each week. These lessons exclude conversation
and are centered on grammar, writing and listening
skills. Schools use textbooks chosen by the
Ministry of Education. A second tiered education
unique to this country is the "Frontesterio,"
or private school. These schools teach a variety
of subjects, with schools usually specializing
in one field only. It is said there are 7,600
Frontesterio in this country with its population
of 12 million. The schools operate from 2 p.m.
till 10 p.m. daily and teach elementary through
to proficiency levels. Frontesterio may use
one of two systems, either the USA Michigan
based system or the UK Cambridge Examinations.
A locally developed exam, the PALSO test for
levels through basic, elementary, to standard
and higher levels are taught.
With all these systems, all areas ranging from
oral communication, writing, grammar, comprehension
and listening are tested. Native English speakers
generally teach from Supplementary materials,
whilst the Greek teacher uses Primary materials.
Students will attend up to 5 or 6 lessons weekly
at these institutions. The PALSO organization,
licensed by the Government, overseas the standards
of schools and such issues as student fees.
Being a European Union nation, Greece tends
to only employ native English speakers from
countries within the E.U. especially Great Britain.
Whilst government schools use rote learning,
Frontesterio tend to apply all modern methodologies.
Teacher centered classrooms are dominant in
government schools. Materials are primarily
developed by Cambridge University or one of
the two Greek based publishing houses, namely
Efstathiadis or Grivas publishers. Books are
specifically developed for the Greek students
with themes of Greek content to stimulate the
student. Contextualized chapters are the emphasis.
This takes Bowens theory (1972) one step further.
Bowen's primary argument was that learners gain
control when focusing on form but lose it once
they focus on the meaning of the message. The
Greek system focuses on picture contrasts primarily,
followed by sound contrast. Students' supplementary
materials are well prepared specifically for
the Greek student with topics of interest to
all.
Oral testing in the Cambridge and PALSO exams
will usually rage from 10 to 20 minutes depending
upon the level of the student. Random topics
are asked, with the exception of the Palso exams
whereby students present a one minute prepared
topic at the beginning, this merely being to
calm nerves.
The
Czech Republic.
Conversely, the Czech Republic has basically
one system, the Government school system. In
it's early stages of democracy, the Czech Republic
has few private schools, though they are appearing
in Prague and Brno more frequently. The government
school system allows each school to develop
or choose its teaching materials. Examinations
are school based and the final "maturita"
year are oral exams. Hence strong emphasis is
placed on pronunciation of the English language,
so native English speakers abound in this country.
Sadly, the quality is somewhat in question,
with local wages being but a fraction of western
salaries, hence the level of teaching can not
be said to be as of yet, 'professional.' A Czech
student will typically receive three to four
lessons a week in English, one usually presented
by a native English speaker. This lesson will
probably come from primary textbook materials,
as supplementary materials are generally non-existent.
However, in the final year of high school, a
Czech student studying English will receive
a double lesson (2 x 45 minutes) of an English
communication lesson. The topic will be those
that that school has decided will be in the
final examination. Each school chooses its topics
from a list provided by the Ministry of Education.
Czech students have difficulty pronouncing "th"
words, so emphasis is often placed on attempting
to correct this problem. Czech students will
usually replace a "th" sound with
a "d" sound. Native Teachers of English
will generally not concentrate on the quality
of pronunciation however, but concentrate on
quality and quantity or reproduced materials.
The grading system, (unlike Greece which breaks
down oral communication into various components
which are assessed individually,) is merely
an A,B,C, or D system, based on nothing more
than objective and subjective feeling by the
examiners. The oral exam is of 15 minutes duration
and covers two separate topics randomly selected
15 minutes before the test.
Korea.
Korea has both the Government school system
and the Private school (hogwon) system. Government
school system. Elementary schools. Teachers
will give two lessons a week to these students.
Schools can choose from a variety of textbooks.
Reading, listening, TPR, chants and videos and
games make up the basis of the lesson. The percentage
of spoken English in a lesson is very high,
running at anywhere from 75 to 90% English.
Recent Government pronouncements have ordered
that at least one lesson in English be 100%
English per week. Whilst admirable in theory,
logically it is impossible.
Teaching emphasis is placed on student centered
teaching with group or pair work the norm. Classrooms
are generally designed to facilitate a friendly
atmosphere, utilizing the Affective system.
However, some teachers are unfamiliar with specific
teaching methodology and know not of the reason
for providing a warm, friendly and reassuring
class atmosphere. Students will present simple
answers, for their vocabulary level is deemed
by the Ministry of Education to be satisfactory
at around 150 to 500 words, depending upon the
year of study.
Middle
schools.
Students will have three - four lessons a week,
from a Korean English teacher whose major at
University was English. Unfortunately, an English
lesson is from a text book chosen by the school
from a series of books submitted by the Korean
Education department, often containing phrases
and sentences that have little or no relevant
meaning, or at times that bear no relationship
to what can be heard in an English speaking
country. The lesson load is unrealistically
demanding and leaves little or no time for the
teacher to practice pronunciation skills with
the students. However, Korean teachers are becoming
quire adept at Evaluating and Adapting materials.
(see McDonough & Shaw 1993)
However, recent changes in Government policy
have seen schools introduce an Oral test. Unfortunately
schools have little or no idea how to conduct
such a test, and little or no idea how to grade
such students. This is partly because class
sizes of 40 students must be assessed in one
forty five-minute period, thus limiting the
test to about 45 seconds per student. Advances
can be expected in this particular area.
Emphasis is still primarily on the written exam
and the listening exam. Following Korea's entry
into IMF controlled financial conditions, the
once populous government native English teacher
population of some 1200 native English teachers
employed specifically to teach in Middle schools,
has been removed wholus bolus from the middle
school system leaving classes devoid of native
English speakers. (Cf. the opinions opined by
professor Pak et al. herein)
High schools do not have spoken English as a
topic, so no mention will be made of this. A
few exceptions exist in special High Schools
whose students are selected as the 'crème
de la crème' of society to study at that
school. There, minimal emphasis is placed on
pronunciation teaching. This questionable policy
is confirmed when one realizes that in first
year university learning oral English is a must
(most institutions) yet students who have gone
from Elementary school English to Middle School
English then suffer a three year hiatus before
returning to the study of English. The hiatus
is too long for fluent continuity.
The Private school system (hogwon) is a booming
industry. These institutions range from the
professionally organized school to the fly by
night schools. Government control, whilst existing,
is generally insufficient. Nevertheless, both
TOEIC, TOEFL and TEPS courses are widely taught,
with preparation for these exams. Unlike the
Government school system, private schools are
blessed with an abundance of Native English
speakers as teachers. Unfortunately, these teachers
are the unqualified class two teachers aforementioned,
who can do little more than hold conversation
lessons without providing a basic understanding
to the students of the principles of second
language learning, let alone pronunciation skills.
Of greater concern to many people both in and
out of Korea, especially at government level,
is the amount of ill will that these private
schools (Hogwons) breed with native English
teachers who come to work for them. Horror stories
abound from native English teachers who encounter
problems such as receiving no pay at all, no
accommodation or substandard accommodation,
no holidays, no severance pay, no sick leave,
despite the written contractual promises.
The Internet is rife with stories of horror.
This is not to say all stories are true, for
they present but one side of the coin, however,
the situation clearly calls for swift and effective
government intervention to clean up an industry
that is causing Korea to receive constant negative
press. Such steps to clean up the industry,
as is seen in Greece, is to set up a watchdog,
either as an autonomous or semiautonomous authority,
manned by both Korean professional educators
and native English educators who can police
effectively complaints and indeed raise the
standard of an industry that desperately needs
raising. |
|